← Back to novel The Last Honest Vote

The Last Honest Vote CHAPTER 17

Chapter 17 — The Answer

6 minute read Chapter 17 of 18

MAKE YOURSELF HEARD

Want to listen to this chapter?

The recording isn’t ready yet. Tell us you’d like it—your request helps us choose what to narrate next.

No sign-up needed. One request per chapter from this browser.

In May, Soto stood in court and tried to say it without saying it.

“I kept hold of her.”

The judge looked down at the agreed account, then back at him.

“After she was restrained?”

“Yes.”

“Mr. Soto, your plea requires me to be satisfied that you understand and admit the offense. I will not accept a phrase that leaves us guessing about your conduct.”

His lawyer touched the document in front of him. She did not touch him.

June was two rows ahead of me. Tomas sat beside her. He had taken his coat off this time and folded it neatly over an empty seat.

I had heard the proposed agreement through the people responsible for informing witnesses, then through Amelia. There had been no request for my permission and no promise that my attendance would make the day easier. Nico was at work. He knew where I was.

Soto looked at his lawyer. She waited.

“I put pressure on her neck,” he said.

“Did you know that prevented her from breathing?”

“Yes.”

“Did you continue?”

“Yes.”

The room was quiet enough for me to hear June turn a page.

He had brought Leah to the warehouse by offering original records. He had restrained her while trying to get back material she had brought and discover what she had copied. She had not attacked him. He had strangled her. Those were the acts he accepted. The softer sentence had nowhere left to go.

The factual account covered the blue cloth beneath the tape on Leah's left wrist, the van, the false collection receipt and the later alteration of the English transcript. The investigators' findings and Marin's statement had been tested against records neither man had expected anyone to put beside them.

The prosecutor read the part concerning Leah's investigation. She was preparing to demonstrate false claims for new arrivals. Some identities had come from Soto's earlier transport records. He faced the loss of the contracts, exposure of the way the old documents had been made and inquiry into what had happened to the people behind them.

Soto's lawyer interrupted over one sentence. There was discussion about what the agreement established and what remained for other cases. They changed no fact by arguing; they narrowed a claim to what he was actually admitting.

The prosecutor asked whether he accepted that he had killed Leah to prevent her using the records against him.

“Yes.”

“Not because she was physically attacking you.”

“No.”

“Not because Mr. Rusk was present directing your actions.”

“He told me to stop the names getting out.”

“That is the message. We're addressing what you did.”

Soto looked away from the lectern.

“Yes,” he said. “I did it.”

For the first time since I had recognized him, his eyes found mine and did not remain there. I had expected something in that look. Hatred. A request. The old reminder that I had chosen the first boat. He looked away before I could decide.


The contact offenses were part of the agreement too. The account separated the plans instead of letting them become one impossible scheme.

At first he had supported the case that placed the responsibility on Rusk. His later instructions matched the changed objective in the message I had seen: keep the case open until he was gone. The committee chair's postponement had been political cover, not a court order stopping an audit. The committee had reversed it once the interference evidence emerged.

The prosecutor put the December-second booking to him. He admitted the journey was meant to be one way. The overseas office would explain his departure; other people were to be left with the grant accounts. Neither the mayor's conviction nor his acquittal would have kept those accounts closed on the chair's announced schedule. Another trial might.

The December journey had not happened. The accounts were restrained. The investigators had taken the passport he would have used.

He had not selected the jury. He had not expected me to report myself along with him. He had recognized a risk and paid to make it wait.

The prosecutor asked whether he had authorized Marin's approach to Owen.

“Yes.”

“And the payment of his rent.”

“Yes.”

“Did Mr. Pike know your part in Ms. Nunez's death?”

“No.”

“Did he know why you wanted time?”

“No.”

That was what Owen had sold without asking. That was what Soto had bought.


The judge accepted the plea after the required questions and findings. There would be sentencing and other proceedings. The man in the defendant's place did not become a different man when the clerk wrote down the result.

Tomas stayed seated until almost everyone else had stood. June put her notebook away and waited beside him.

In the corridor she introduced us properly. He looked at me as if he had known my face for months and was only now being required to meet the person behind it.

“You gave them the old paper,” he said.

“Yes.”

“She asked you for it.”

“She asked if I had information. I denied it.”

He pressed a thumb into the fold of his coat.

“I don't know what to say to you.”

“You don't have to say anything.”

“People keep telling me that. Then they stand there waiting.”

I stepped back. June took his arm and they went toward the stairs. He did not turn around. I did not call after him.

Outside, I sat on a low wall until the stone had warmed through my clothes.


At Rusk's later proceeding I sat near the back. His case had been resolved through an agreement on offenses he would admit and the prosecution could establish. His lawyers still disputed the murder theory. Nothing about that made his own instructions vanish.

When the prosecutor read the message, Rusk looked at the people beside him instead of the judge.

She doesn't leave with those names. Handle it tonight.

“You sent that?”

“Yes.”

“And you provided access to the building.”

“Yes.”

The factual account described the pressure and intimidation he authorized and his subsequent concealment of the arrangements. The prosecutor asked whether he accepted it.

“I never wanted—”

His lawyer spoke quietly to him. The judge waited.

Rusk looked at the text again.

“I accept the account,” he said.

He received years in prison, not the lifetime sought in the first case. Outside afterward, a supporter with a yellow badge told a camera that justice had finally prevailed. I walked past her. I had heard what he admitted.

Owen admitted the interference and received a prison sentence. The rent records and communications gathered independently of his compelled testimony had followed him into his own case. His mother cared for his daughter. Marin's cooperation was weighed alongside the acts he admitted, not in place of them. The financial cases continued through papers and hearings most people stopped watching.

My own position remained with Amelia and the other advice she had obtained. Nobody gave me a certificate saying that providing evidence had canceled the false statements that preceded it. Some clients wanted to wait. Some never called again. I worked on written translation and payment plans.

Nico started opening the electricity bills before putting them beside my plate.

In September he brought the school project home in a new folder. Every page was there.

“I want to do another one,” he said.

“For what?”

“For me, mostly.” He put a notebook beside it. “Will you help?”

He had written two headings on the first page: WHAT WE KNOW and WHAT WE DON'T.

“No grade,” he said, and went to make coffee.

End of chapter 17